Monday, July 6th, 2009
Athens
I set down my knife and fork and turned around in my chair to watch Alleke and the handful of other kids who had come with their parents to dine at this restaurant, which amounted to a few checkerboard tables in the corner of an empty square at the end of one of the tiny streets that ran back and forth up the side of the mountain to the Acropolis, where the Parthenon sat perched like a crown over the city.
The kids were infinitely more excited about the empty square in which they could run around freely and the cat that they had found sleeping under one of the tables. I watched for a while as they huddled around the table and giggled as the cat batted his paws at a piece of straw one of the little girls had found.
Eventually we returned to the conversation April and I were having with my parents about how they had noticed that a lot of tourists were taking pictures of Alleke, sometimes even when we weren’t aware of it. They had seen this a number of times since they were usually walking behind us.
“Do you want strangers taking pictures of your daughter?” my mom asked.
I looked at April and shrugged. “I don’t know,” I said.
When Alleke was younger, I didn’t mind when people took pictures of her. I liked it, actually, because it meant people thought she was cute, and so did I. Alleke was growing up fast, however, and lately she had become more self conscious. She was shy when she met new people. She would come running over and hide behind my leg or beg me to pick her up so she could hide her face in my chest.
She was old enough to know that it’s not normal for strangers to take pictures of her.
“How do you think Alleke feels about strangers taking pictures of her?” my mom asked.
I glanced over my shoulder to see where Alleke was. I couldn’t find her at first until I noticed an over-weight woman in a sun hat at the far end of the square lifting Alleke onto a stone bench. I watched as the women took out her camera, asked Alleke to smile, and took her picture.
“Alleke, Alleke” April called, “Kelly, go get her.”
I bolted out of my chair, and by the time I reached Alleke I had already frightened the woman so badly she was hurrying down the street and around the corner, holding onto her sun hat with one hand and dragging her husband behind her with the other.
Still enraged, I grabbed Alleke by the arm and marched off towards to our table. Alleke broke free and stopped. Just before she turned her back to me and crossed her arms, I saw the tears streaming down her face.
“Why did daddy do that?” Alleke asked, sniffling.
I just stood there for a while, not sure what to say. I had over-reacted, there was no question about that, and instead of protecting Alleke from an unwanted situation, I had put her in one, making her feel like she had done something wrong and embarrassing her.
I sighed. “I thought you didn’t want that woman to take your picture,” I said.
For more, take a look at our photos from Greece…
MORE ON: alleke, athens, greece, parenting, toddler, travel
6 COMMENTS
I was in Malaga aiprot last year with my then 1 year old son … asleep in his stroller.. when two German tourists (two older ladies) came over and asked if they could take their picture with my son – each one took a picture of the other kneeling next to his stroller… I thought it was so weird… I just said yes but I never really understood why they did it…. he is a cutie for sure.. and very blond…. but they were German – surely they werent that intrigued by his blond hair?
July 6, 2009 at 2:56 pm
I find this post curious – I'm interested in photography and people in general make interesting topics. I would never touch a child or ask them to pose – and even if I were going to I would make sure the parents and the child were ok with it. But lately I have been wondering if it's OK to take candid shots of people. I understand how it may make the subject uncomfortable, so I tend to hold back, but sometimes a situation is too good a photo-op to pass up. My pictures are just for my own artwork – to look at for the sake of memories or to frame as purely art. But still, I wonder if I should not take pictures of peopleever.
July 6, 2009 at 6:26 pm
I am once again surprised how trusting you are of the people around you and of your daughter.
July 6, 2009 at 6:36 pm
A challenging situation. I am not sure what I would choose to do. It makes me wonder – does it weird us out more because people are intentionally taking a picture or because the picture is being taken in and of itself? If Alleke happened to appear in someone's picture unintentionally (candidly) would it be as weird feeling? Like I said, I'm not sure what I think or what I would do either but I know that you are thoughtful, wise parents and will always seek the best for your children, even if it makes you uncomfortable at times.
I love your photos from Greece – one of several places on my list to visit before I die. Thanks again for sharing with us.
July 8, 2009 at 7:48 pm
Chloe, I think you're on to something here. For me personally I think it has less to do with Alleke being in someone else's picture and more to do with Alleke watching other people take pictures of her without her permission or ours.
Alleke looks very different from the rest of the kids she interacts with in our neighborhood, and it's worth mentioning that people take pictures of her a lot. It's a regular occurrence. As her dad, I'm more concerned about how she understands her identity in the culture where she lives, especially as she becomes more self conscious of herself and others.
July 9, 2009 at 7:20 amLEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Hi, my name is Kelly and I write about being a dad. Let me tell you
Manuscript is complete. April is reading it for the first time.

Anonymous said...
I think it's so strange that anyone would take a photo of an unknown child, especially without permission from the parents. Do people seriously think this is normal or okay? Yikes.
July 6, 2009 at 2:44 pm