Tuesday, March 18th, 2008
Swimmers, Snorkelers and Fish
This post is part of a series called Spring Cleaning where I asked you, the reader, if there was anything you wanted to know, but never asked about me or my family. Today’s question was asked by Sandra77:
Is Spain now home for you, April and Alleke? Do you think you’ll return to the US to live? Would you live in other cities in Europe? I’m curious about whether Americans who are not retirees really make the switch to permanent living outside of the U.S.

Alleke at the pool last summer
Living in a foreign country often feels like that game we would play at the pool as kids where we would try to see how long we could hold our breath under water. Mostly we played to see who could last the longest, but also because it was fascinating to be under water where everything looked and sounded differently.
Using water as my analogy, I feel like when it comes to living in a foreign country there are three kinds of people: swimmers, snorkelers, and fish.
Swimmers (holding your breath)
As kids at the pool, we had to come up for air at some point. It was inevitable. In my experience, most people who live abroad are holding their breath. They want to see how long they can last. They come to see the world from a different angle, and they study or work temporary jobs so they can experience the local culture. Most eventually return home to be closer to friends and family or pursue a career.
Snorkelers (sucking air through a tube)
Others, like us, are snorkeling. We found jobs at home that sent us to work in a foreign country. In our case, April and I work for an international church called Oasis Madrid, and as such, were hired by an international non-profit organization that pays us from home. This is a viable means of living in a foreign country, but it’s fragile. If anything happens to that snorkel tube, we need to come up for air. Exchange rates and permission to work in a foreign country can change. Plus, most international organizations and companies, like the military, expect their employees to move every couple years, making it difficult to settle down somewhere and integrate. April and I love our jobs, and plan to keep them, but if we wanted to stay in Spain and change careers, it would be very difficult because we found our jobs at home, not here. Our education and experience from home don’t translate very well.
Fish (breathing water)
To live in a foreign country permanently means to completely reinvent yourself. In other words, if you want to breath under water, you have to learn to be a fish. I haven’t met very many fish, and by that I mean I haven’t met many non-European couples who have moved to Spain, found Spanish jobs, and plan to stay. After a year or two, most people decide it’s not worth the trouble, and they realize they don’t want to be fish. They miss their families, or the familiarity of their own culture, or they realize they could get a better job at home.
Let’s face it, those from the foreign country will almost always be more qualified for most jobs. They speak the language, they intuitively know how things work, and they have a base of friends and family who support them. Learning to be a fish is not simply a matter of putting in enough time and effort, it means countless people going out of their way to listen to you fumble along in a language that’s not your own, rent you a room or an apartment when they don’t know much about you or your culture, and give you a job when others are more qualified. It can happen, but it’s a slow process.
All this to say…
Sandra, all of this may be more than you wanted to know, and I’m not sure I even have any answers to your actual questions. What I do know is I didn’t expect April and I to be some of the few internationals I know who still live in Spain. I really don’t know why we stayed, and they left. Many of them seemed more fit for Spain than us, and what makes it even more bizarre is we liked living in the US and we love our families, so it’s not like we didn’t give up a lot to move here.
I suppose we stay because a) we are a part of a very close-knit group of people in our church who care about us, which makes us feel like we belong here, b) we believe our jobs are important and help make Spain a better place, which gives us a purpose for being here beyond just seeing the world from another perspective, and c) Spain (specifically Madrid, and even more specifically our neighborhood) challenges us to be the kind of people we want to be. So, we feel like Spain helps us to be better people.
Continue with this series by reading my answer to Valerie’s question:
My husband and I are being transferred to Spain this summer and we have two small boys (2 1/2 & 1). I was just wondering if you had any suggestions for a daily schedule for toddlers? I planned on slowly transitioning my boys into a Spanish time frame for things before we arrived. Read my answer…
11 COMMENTS
Excellent analysis. I think I’d end up a swimmer or snorkler.
March 19, 2008 at 3:15 pm
Kelly, I’ve been reading for a long time but have never commented. (I’m Johanna Rohde’s sister).
I like this analogy! Out of curiosity, where would you fit in the children of people who choose to live internationally? And, as Alleke grows up overseas, how do you see her developing culturally? More as an American, more as a Spaniard or a strong mix of the two?
March 19, 2008 at 5:48 pm
OK for selfish reasons, I think you should be a swimmer!
March 19, 2008 at 7:59 pm
Yes, that would be Monica. Thought I would clarify since April has only one sister too!!!
March 19, 2008 at 8:02 pm
Hi Jenn. Thanks for your comment. We met Eva and Daniel recently, and they said they’re good friends of yours.
Anyway, in answer your questions, I think you’re the expert here, no? As your questions suggest, it’s helpful to point out that many people move to foreign countries either because their parents have made that decision for them, or because they are married / living with someone from that country.
For me, these two situations change the scenario completely. Yes, the challenge is integration, but even more so identity. Where do I belong? It’s not so much a question of whether you want to live in the foreign country and can make it work, but more about belonging somewhere even when your family doesn’t exactly fit in one place or the other.
As for Alleke, because I see her situation as quite different than mine, I’ve been reading books on Third Culture Kids. I have a lot more to learn about her experience…any advice you can give would be greatly appreciated!
March 19, 2008 at 10:50 pm
Gr8 Post! buddy.Thanks for sharing.
keep up the work.
Your perspective is very interesting, and very different from immigrants, who have to “become fishes” in almost every instance. As a Filipino whose parents were immigrants, and who come from a culture of fishes, this is something I see all the time. When people have to make do in another country, they make do. When they have to compete, they compete. They adopt, they grow scales, they master the language, etc. etc.
Anyway, great blog. Alleke is so cute.
March 22, 2008 at 5:45 am
We having saying,that east, west,south, north home is best. l know the feeling of living in a new place.
March 22, 2008 at 4:14 pm
From observing our friends/neighbors from the Netherlands I would suggest a bit of a modification. They came here and started a business, and in many ways are better at it than those of us whom are native. They are the ones providing jobs and people are competing for their business. I think being a businessman with money makes a big difference over someone looking for a job in a different culture. With that in mind too, there are a lot of people in my business that would rather hire a nonnative Hispanic than a local person because of perceived work ethic. Even if they were to pay them the same wage.
That is just my thoughts on competing in the marketplace, as for fitting into the culture that is totally different.
Hi, I love your blog and have given you an award on my blog today.
March 26, 2008 at 9:21 amLEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Hi, my name is Kelly and I write about being a dad. Let me tell you
Do you know a literary agent?
Sandra77 said...
Kelly, thank you for such a wonderful answer to my question! I suspected that making the transition to living in a different country, particularly one with a different language, would be challenging, and that fewer people that expected would actually be up to (or want to take up) that challenge. I still plan to come to Spain, but I keep asking myself how committed I am to staying and how I will be able to support myself (those pesky practical questions!). I think that’s one of the reasons that I am so interested in you and your family’s life in Madrid – I am trying to get a feel for real, everyday life in Spain, and I think I get that from reading your blog. Thanks again.
March 19, 2008 at 12:17 pm